Connect with us

General

Ball Mills Or Vertical Roller Mills: Which Is Better For Cement Grinding?

Vertical roller mills Vs ball mills has long been a raging debate in the cement industry. In spite of the fact that vertical roller mills have been around for over ten years now and have gradually become the standard as far as cement manufacturing goes, several cement manufacturers still prefer ball mills for cement production when they want to design new grinding plants or a new integrated cement plant.

Some members of the cement manufacturing industry, it appears, is stuck in the past rather than embracing newer, energy saving and better technological advancement. They should notice the following differences and make an informed choice.

Ball Mills Or Vertical Roller Mills: Which Is Better For Cement Grinding?

Mill Operation and Maintenance

Operating a ball mill is quite simple as it lacks any moving mechanical parts within the mill. The system is quite versatile and is designed to accommodate variation in mill feed quantity and quality.  On the other hand, the vertical roller mills (VRM) is quite a complicated and sophisticated equipment with hydraulics that controls the rollers.

The material between the table and the rollers is quite thin, and it is important that the rollers and the table are not in contact with each other. If the material bed is variable, it results in vibrations in the mill.

In VRMs, the effect of this vibration is reduced as the feed is larger than that in cement mill feed. The amount of moisture in the kiln raw materials is higher than that of the cement mill. To reduce the vibration effect and prepare the materials, the rollers of the VRM are suitably modified.

Sometimes, grooved rollers are used to establish and remove the air content of the materials within a low-pressure area before it is passed on to a high-pressure grinding area where the material are then fractured. Sometimes, smaller rollers may be used to before the first rollers to achieve the same outcome.

Regarding operations, in a ball mill, the grinding media has a higher rate of wear about the rollers and table in the VRM. In ball mills, it is essential to monitor its performance via axial testing to ascertain that the media grading is right and that there are enough top-size media to grind the mill feed materials. If not so, high, underground materials (referred to as nibs) will collect around the edge of the first chamber.

In ball mills, the main repairs that occur are replacing the diaphragms and liners. The lifespan of the liners is about five years for the liners in the first chamber and up to eight years for those in the second chamber. They, therefore do not require frequent replacement.

The diaphragm plates, however, need to be replaced more often, though not annually. On the other hand, the major repairs in vertical roller mills are replacing the rollers (or turning it) and the table. Though you may not have to replace the worn parts of the VRM yearly, however, work needs to be done on them. This could involve either reverse its roller segments or hard-facing the rollers and table.

Eventually, you just would have to replace the worn parts. Thus, VRM requires higher maintenance than ball mills. On the whole,  the maintenance costs are almost at par. The rate of wear is greater in a ball mill but the cost of replacement is lower. On the other hand, the wear rate is lower in VRM, the cost of replacing the parts is significantly higher.

Product Quality

When VRM was first mooted as an alternative in cement production, one of its seeming challenges was its particle size distribution (PSD). Due to their high separation efficiency and its high circulation factor, VRM tends to produce cement with a steep PSD curve unlike those generated by ball mills.

Cement with a steep PSD is one with a high water demand.  To address this issue, VRM manufacturers have come up with a more conventional raw mill VRM design.

Investment Cost

VRM has been a more compact unit is quite smaller about the ball mills thus significantly reducing civil engineering cost about a ball mill plant. Ball mills are factory made and transported to the plant site of the buyer while VRM is built on the site of the cement plant. This helps to reduce cost and complicated logistics issues. The equipment cost is, however, higher for a VRM than a ball mill.

So these are the pros and cons of the two technologies and a cement manufacturing company mus consider to make the suitable choice that matches their requirements.

Continue Reading

Recent Posts

Home Improvement2 months ago

How To Add More Value To Your Home

If you have some spare cash in the bank, it is likely you would like to spend it on your...

Lifestyle2 months ago

What is a Deep Plane Facelift

Cosmetic surgery is a choice that needs a lot of research and when it comes to thinking about a facelift...

Entrepreneur2 months ago

Unveiling the Demand for Digital Marketing Courses: A Comprehensive Analysis

In recent years, the realm of marketing has undergone a seismic shift propelled by the digital revolution. As businesses increasingly...

Home Improvement2 months ago

What Does an Effective Wardrobe Spring Clean Entail?

Spring is upon us which means one thing and one thing only. It is time for the annual purge of...

Business4 months ago

Your Basic Guide To Creating A Unique Investment Blog

Starting your own blog is great and once you get the ball rolling, it can be a good passive income...

Business4 months ago

3 Low-Risk Ways To Get Your New Business Started

Once you’ve got an initial business idea and believe that it will be a success, there are some basic things...

Lifestyle4 months ago

Conquering the Co-free Zone: Tips for Thriving as a Remote Worker

Adjusting to an office environment can come with its downfalls in the sense that it might be a shock to...

General5 months ago

3 Ways To Take Control Of Your Finances Starting Now

If your finances have taken over and are bringing stress to your life, we understand just how overwhelming it can...

Travel7 months ago

Best Places To Visit In The North Of England

If you live in England, you will know there are many different places to visit for the weekend. There are...

General7 months ago

Green Home Improvement Ideas

In a world where environmental concerns are growing, the concept of “green” has gone beyond a trendy catchphrase and is...

Lifestyle7 months ago

How to Host an Unforgettable House-Warming!

The time has finally come. You have moved into your dream pad, and are officially adulting in your very own...

Autos7 months ago

A Guide to Parking Lot Striping

The journey to a well-striped parking lot begins with the right paint. In this brief guide, we’ll unravel the mystery...

Business10 months ago

Business Tips For Protecting Your Finances During A Recession

In 2023, taking the necessary steps to protect your finances for your business is now more important than ever. The...

Lifestyle11 months ago

Tips For Cleaning Your Trainers

If you’re into your trainers and streetwear, you’re likely to be very conscious of keeping them looking their best! So,...

Marketing11 months ago

Branding Trends For Start-Ups in 2023

Branding is incredibly important as it impacts how your business reaches and connects with its target market. If you’re branding...

Categories

Archives

Trending