Connect with us

Law

The Most Eagerly Anticipated Supreme Court Cases

The Most Eagerly Anticipated Supreme Court Cases

Every October, the Supreme Court of the United States convenes for a new judicial term. This fall, many important cases will come before the court, many which will be nationally notable and controversial. In the 2012-2013 session, decisions overturning the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) and a key portion of the Voting Rights Act of 1964 (Shelby County v. Holder) were a few of the headlines in one of the more tumultuous sessions in recent memory.

It should be noted that the Court, convening on October 7, 2013, already tossed out hundreds of appeals that were awaiting a hearing by the justices. This included the denial of Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli’s request for a review of a lower court’s decision to throw out Virginia’s ban on certain types of sexual acts under its anti-sodomy law (William Scott MacDonald vs. Tim Moose, et al. 2013).

The Most Eagerly Anticipated Supreme Court Cases

Here are three of the biggest cases on the docket this term.

McCutcheon et al. vs. Federal Election Commission

The Court has been given the opportunity to extend its thinking in the Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission (2010) case that gave free speech rights to corporations. On Tuesday, October 8, 2013 the court heard oral arguments in the case of Shaun McCutcheon et al. v. Federal Election Commission. Petitioner McCutcheon is a prominent Republican donor and owner of Coalmont Electrical Development based in Tuscaloosa County, Alabama. McCutcheon and his counsel contend that the financial donation limits are unconstitutionally low.

In arguments before the court on Tuesday, it appeared that conservative justices — including Samuel Alito, Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas — were in agreement with the points made by petitioner’s counsel while more liberal justices — Stephen Breyer, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Elena Kagan, and Sonia Sotomayer –sided with the government’s arguments that the power to decide elections will be placed in the hands of small minority if aggregate limits are eliminated. Interestingly, the swing vote in this all-important case that could impact future federal elections is not Justice Anthony Kennedy. Instead, Chief Justice John Roberts, who appears to be on the fence on this issue, may provide the pivotal vote on what is expected to be a 5-4 decision.

Township of Mount Holly vs. Mt. Holly Gardens Citizens in Action, Inc. 

A plan put forth by the Township of Mount Holly to redevelop a tract of blighted housing in a development known as The Garden has sparked controversy over an interpretation of the 1968 Fair Housing Act. At issue is whether the action of the township to replace the existing housing with a new complex will result in a disproportionate negative effect — “disparate impact” — on The Garden’s current residents, many of who are low-income African Americans and Latinos.

The case began in 2002 when a plan to buy out residents of The Gardens under its eminent domain powers surfaced. The federal district court in New Jersey granted a summary judgment for the township, stating that the respondents failed to establish either intentional discrimination or a prima facie case of disparate impact by the town. The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit reversed the lower court’s judgment, setting the stage for this landmark case.

Schuette vs. Michigan Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action  

The case of Schuette vs. Michigan Coalition involves the passage of a ban on racial preferences in education that was part of a statewide voter’s referendum in 2006. At issue is not any specific affirmative action measure — as was the case in Gratz v. Bollinger (2003), which overturned the University of Michigan’s affirmative action admissions policy — but rather the constitutionality of a statewide ban on such practices.

Byline

Randall Stewart writes on law, society, politics & finance. Randall recommends that those who need help with an Asbestos Lawsuit consult with Shrader Law for experienced professional assistance.

Image credit goes to deltaMike.

Continue Reading

Recent Posts

Home Improvement1 week ago

Mastering The Maintenance: Breaking Down The Basics Of Your Ducted Heating And Cooling System

Welcome, fellow home enthusiasts! Ever find yourself lost in the labyrinth of your ducted heating and cooling system? Have you...

Business3 weeks ago

The Invisible Hands: Unveiling How Food Distributors Influence the Quality of Our Foods

Ever found yourself wondering why the tomatoes in your salad taste particularly fresh or why your preferred brand of coffee...

Marketing3 weeks ago

Webflow CMS: A Comprehensive Guide

Webflow is a powerful tool that allows you to create and manage dynamic websites without needing to code. It’s a...

Business3 weeks ago

The Three Most Important Benefits You Should Offer To Your Employees

Offering your employees a range of benefits on top of regular salary increases will really help to show that you...

Business1 month ago

Business Tips For Protecting Your Finances During A Recession

In 2024, taking the necessary steps to protect your finances for your business is now more important than ever. The...

Green & Energy2 months ago

Air Conditioning Installation: What You Need to Know

When it comes to getting an air conditioning unit installed, can significantly improve your comfort and home environment, especially during...

Marketing2 months ago

Marketing Tips For A Gym Wear Brand

When starting a gym wear brand, there are a few things you need to do and one of them is...

General2 months ago

Social Media Marketing: What Are All The Types?

Social media marketing is a tool that is a must-have in today’s digital age. it’s very rare that businesses can...

Business3 months ago

How To Become A Property Developer

There are several reasons why an individual will want to become a property developer. One of the main reasons for...

Business3 months ago

Remote Delivery Innovations: Case Studies from Leading E-commerce Brands

People have gone through much change in the past few years when it comes to online shopping. Nowadays, when delivery...

Business3 months ago

Why are Brits turning to online-only banks?

For years, large, conventional banks held all the aces when it comes to citizens’ finances in the UK. HSBC, Lloyds...

5 Important Web Design Considerations to Make For Better SEO 5 Important Web Design Considerations to Make For Better SEO
Tech4 months ago

5 Important Web Design Considerations to Make For Better SEO

Ever since the birth of search engines, practices in optimising websites for better search rankings have changed considerably. Where it...

SEO4 months ago

The Importance of Local SEO for Small Businesses

There are many different types of businesses and all of them will require online marketing however, with a small business,...

General4 months ago

Understanding The Unsung Heroes: Cool Rooms And The Importance Of Regular Repairs

Everybody loves a breath of fresh air when entering a superstore! But have you ever wondered who’s working backstage to...

Home Improvement8 months ago

How To Add More Value To Your Home

If you have some spare cash in the bank, it is likely you would like to spend it on your...

Categories

Archives

Trending